Examining A Cure For Our Communities Criminology Essay

The U.S. has to happen ways to turn “ tax-consuming inmates into tax-paying, observant citizens ” ( Tecco, 2009 ) . New techniques have to go on to be developed, because traditional rehabilitation plans do non look to hold permanent effects. The rate of recidivism is still far above 60 % for those rearrested within the first 3 old ages of being released. These new plans have to widen base on balls the prison walls to assist the released captive successfully run in their communities. Many ex-convicts are continually contending a system that denies them the rights and privileges as others. One of the major illustrations of this is the ability to derive employment. Many released captives are seeking to better themselves, but without a steady occupation to take attention of their day-to-day lives, it becomes easier to turn back to their old life of offense.

Understanding recidivism is the first measure in making a scheme to diminish the nation-wide spread. Before anything can be done, there must be a realistic end set that is hoped to be reached. The thought of wholly halting recidivism would be in a perfect universe, but non realistic. Recidivism will ever happen, merely as offense will ne’er halt. The attack should non be to halt recidivism right off, but to set up methods that will do a continual lessening as clip returns. In recent old ages the United States became the taking state with the highest rate of captivity of any state. The U.S. is non ranked in the top offense states, but better yet

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 6

known for stronger sentencing and drug policies. This is to make the image of being tough on offense and less tolerable towards felons. Unlike the U.S. , other states focus bulk of their attempts on attacks like offense bar plans and rehabilitation to cut down offense.

Purpose for Research

There are really small empirical histories in which literature on recidivism as shown that intervention intercessions or correctional plans have lowered the recidivism rates significantly. Many researches has concluded that it recidivism rates are really hard to influences. Recidivism is measured by condemnable Acts of the Apostless that resulted in the re-arrest, reconviction, or return to prison with or without a new sentence during a three-year period following the captive ‘s release. Harmonizing to Tecco ( 2009 ) the prison industry makes about $ 60billion yearly and even with this, there are merely a few productive plans seeking to work out the more serious jobs like assisting released inmates find employment.

The captivity rate in the United States indicates that the correctional system is more alternatively in increasing its population over diminishing it. If the U.S. was to set more fundss into rehabilitation, so research shows that although the short-run cost would be high, if the plans are successful in cut downing recidivism, so it will demo to be good worth the cost in the terminal.


Majority of the research words that will be used in this undertaking is defied that can assist the reader understand the information gathered. Recidivism is a inclination to get worse into a old status or manner of behaviour ; particularly, backsliding into condemnable behaviour. Recidivism Rate is the behaviour of a repetition or accustomed felon. A measuring of the rate at which wrongdoers commit other offenses, either by apprehension or strong belief baselines, and this occurs after being released from

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 7

captivity. Rehabilitation in this undertaking is the purpose at transforming an wrongdoer into a valuable member of society. The primary end is to forestall farther discourtesy by converting the wrongdoer that their behavior was incorrect.

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 8

Chapter 2


My research is based on scholarly diaries and public authorities information. Recidivism is non merely hard to prove and analyze, but it is really hard to research. The ability to record and maintain path of a big group of people over an drawn-out period of clip can be really clip consuming and dearly-won to a individual or individuals who wish to analyze this subject. Most of the information is guess and theory of possibilities. Not merely will this research proposal discuss many of these theories, but use existent life conducted experiments and survey development.

Percentages of Recidivism

U.S. Department of Justice and the Bureau of Justice Statistics showed the consequences of a survey conducted in 1994, reported by Dr. Langan and Dr. Levin ( 2002 ) . The survey was conducted utilizing 272,111 released inmates. The survey showed that the highest degrees of recidivism occur within the first twelvemonth of a captive ‘s release. This accounted for about two-thirds of all recidivism in the first three old ages of release. The Doctors reported that it was estimated that 21.5 % of the 272,111 inmates were reconvicted for a new felony or misdemeanour within that first twelvemonth period. After the 2nd twelvemonth at that place was another 14.9 % reconvicted giving a two twelvemonth combined sum of 36.4 % . And after the 3rd twelvemonth released another 10.5 % of the inmates were rearrested, in merely three old ages after their release, about half of the 272,111 inmates were back in prison confronting other strong beliefs.

In that first 3 old ages, 67.5 % of the captives were rearrested for a new discourtesy that they had committed and out of that 67.5 % there were 46.9 % that really faced strong beliefs for that

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 9

offense. 51.8 % were back in prison, functioning a new prison sentence for a proficient misdemeanor of their release. A proficient misdemeanor could be neglecting a drug trial, losing an assignment with their parole officer, or holding jobs with jurisprudence enforcement.

The survey showed that the highest reconviction rates were captives that were antecedently centrifugal vehicle stealers made up 78.8 % , inmates in possessing or selling stolen belongings made up 77.4 % , burglars made up 74.0 % , larceners made up 74.6 % , robbers and those with illegal arms made up 70.2 % . And on the low terminal of reconvictions were those incarcerated for homicide they made up 40.7 % . Within that three twelvemonth clip period 1.2 % of those who had served clip for homicide were rearrested for homicide. Those convicted of colza made up 46.0 % and 2.5 % of rapers were reconvicted for another colza. Other sexual assault outside of colza made up 41.4 % , and driving under the influence was on the higher terminal with 51.5 % that were rearrested.

The survey showed that work forces were 10.8 % more likely to be rearrested so adult females. Blacks were 10.2 % more likely to be rearrested them Whites and non-Hispanics were 6.8 % more likely so Hispanics. Age besides made a difference ; the survey showed that younger captives were more likely to recommit offenses than older captives.

A 2nd study came in that followed/tracked 300,000 released captives out of 15 provinces on their reconvictions re-arrest and re-incarceration over a 3 twelvemonth period, it showed that 67.5 % were rearrested, 46.9 % were reconvicted, and 25.4 % were resentenced for new condemnable charges within that 3 old ages period. These 300,000 inmates represent two-thirds on the released population in the United States in 1994.

A 3rd study was released in 2007 utilizing a sum of 1,180,469 released captives on word. There were 16 % of the probationers that had returned to prison that really twelvemonth. It was reported that these wrongdoers had accumulated over 4 million charges before their most recent

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 10

imprisonment and one time released there was another 744,000 felon charges giving within the 3 twelvemonth release period. Each of these surveies shows the same consequences all across the universe. They give in-site into the survey of recidivism in the fact that the first three old ages are the most of import clip to assist and document the success of bar plans. A recidivism bar plan has to be set up to non merely assist the inmate while in prison, but one time they are released, when contending enticement truly gets hard.

Active Programs in the U.S

The United States has many plans set in topographic point to assist inmates and former inmates to turn away from a life of offense and go active citizens of the community. Florida ‘s Department of Corrections has an academic, vocational, and substance maltreatment plans to help inmates to cut down recidivism after release. A survey was conducted utilizing 18,414 released inmates. The survey focused on the impacts of each of the plans the Departments has and the consequences that each had on former inmates. The research focused on the impact of plan completion. They besides, observed the impact of plans grouping inmate ‘s gender, race, condemnable history and other major forecasters of recidivism. Last, the impact of the plans was measured by the achieved betterments in academic accomplishments, work experience, and good disciplinary records while incarcerated.

The impact of the plans is exemplified by the per centum of former inmates that did non relapse or the success rate. The results were compared utilizing those inmates that had completed the plans and those who had non. The first plan examined is the Academic program/GED plan. This gives inmates the chance to complete school, construct their assurance and give them trust for life after prison. Harmonizing to Moore ( 2001 ) former inmates who had earn their GED while in prison, are over 8 % less likely to relapse so those who

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 11

hold non earned a GED. This puts the success rate for GED holder over 70 % after they are released.

There is an added fillip for those inmates who earn a GED and have occupation experience, in the manner of increasing their per centum from 8 % to over 10 % of being less likely to relapse. This is why the Department has added a Vocational plan. Puting instruction and see together can be a merely want a former inmates demands to hold a fresh start. The Vocational plan is has a really high success rate if inmates complete the plan. Former inmates are over 14 % less likely to relapse one time released if they complete this plan.

The last plan is the Substance Abuse plans. These plans are really of import, because harmonizing to U.S. Department of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics. ( 1998 ) any where form 45-75 % of all felons test positive for some kind of substance maltreatment. The survey showed that inmates who had a history of condemnable behaviour related to substance maltreatment that had completed the plan was over 13 % less likely to relapse so those who had non completed the plan. After reexamining the consequences of each plan and analyzing recidivism after release, the Florida Department of Corrections is allowing other bureaus know that former inmates that complete plans set to assist them get the better of challenges and range ends are more successful after release so those who do non inscribe or finish the plans.

The province of New York conducts a different plan that does non merely trades with an inmate ‘s readiness for release, but effort to alter their ethical motives and manner of life. The survey was to detect what impact, if any did faith hold on recidivism. The surveies conducted by Johnson, B. et a cubic decimeter ( 1997 ) and Evans, T. et Al ( 1996 ) both has the same lineation and decision. They both took two groups which one was involved in the Prison Fellowship plan and the other group had no association with any faith. Both surveies showed that increased spiritual

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 12

activities had a negative association with offense and/or delinquent activity. This shows that turning to faith can alter the manner a individual Acts of the Apostless and possible thinks.

Tocqueville ( 1833 ) conducted a survey that found that rehabilitation and reformation are in fact two different things. He said that if a individual has been rehabilitated it can be measured, but whether a individual has been reformed there no manner to state. Detecting released inmates can demo if they have been rehabilitated by their actions, but penitence comes from within. Just because a individual does non perpetrate offenses does non intend they are a good individual with good ideas. There is no manner to cognize how a individual is believing with them stating. A solution to this could be to hold former inmates to sit in with a psychological sciences and speaking about their ideas of offense when an chance present itself. Knowing the reply to inquiries such as this could let research workers to cognize if a individual is non merely rehabilitated, but reformed every bit good.

His survey did hold restrictions, but Tocqueville acknowledged that “ our findings at least suggest that spiritual plans have the possible to impact former inmates ‘ behaviour after release. Because spiritual plans are outstanding in most prisons and because such plans are used widely, it would look logical to organize the two subjects more to the full in future research — foremost, by measuring the influence of faith or spiritual plans on accommodation to prison and secondly, by analyzing the long-run recidivism forms of inmates who are released ” ( 1833 ) .

Rehabilitation can come in many signifiers ; one that seems to work really good is the Entrepreneurship plan that helps captives redirect their condemnable motivations into positive countries. This plan takes drug-dealers and pack leaders who have shown traits of entrepreneurial in their condemnable behaviour and teaches them MBA degree categories so they can larn how to utilize their street cognition in a positive manner. Over old ages of perpetrating a assortment of offenses, felons have

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 13

go really good knowing in Math, Science and other Fieldss of survey without cognizing that they have learned a accomplishment. And demoing captive how to utilize them knowledge in a positive manner could give them the hope they need to non re-offend one time released.

Many of the plans that are implemented around the U.S. are used to educated and learn, but in Kansas there is a plan called Puppies behind Bars. This plan is non to educate, but to assist violent wrongdoer to detect their lost humanity. The plan takes stateless Canis familiariss and lucifers them with violent wrongdoers to give them the chance to care for another living thing. These inmates raise these puppies to one twenty-four hours function as service Canis familiariss for the handicapped and to be used in jurisprudence enforcement bureaus. This is one of many alternate plans that prisons use besides the instruction plans.

Theater and art plans are besides a great manner for captives to better cognitive behaviour and learn to show their egos without utilizing force. Giving inmates the ability to show their emotions in words, art or authorship can give them off to manage nerve-racking state of affairss and get down new avocations to busy their clip one time paroled. This give them a manner to let go of defeat that may be bottled up and construct assurance.

Last, Yoga and speculation plans have become a good rehabilitation tool used within some prisons. Yoga helps the human organic structure release emphasis, depression, and anxiousness though organic structure motions and controlled external respiration. Surveies have shown that is a individual maintains a long term pattern of these methods it can do a alteration in one ‘s mentality on life and behaviour.

Active Programs in other Sectors

All across the universe recidivism is a factor that has to be addressed and discussed. Developing plans in other states are merely as of import has in the U.S. Harmonizing to Schmid ( 2001 ) when societal development of kids and households are encouraged there is a

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 14

lessening in condemnable activity. There is a greater return to the state if a released captive does non recidivism. There will be a $ 7.00 return for every $ 1.00 spent on rehabilitating them. In most states each family would hold to increase their revenue enhancements by $ 228 if they hope to diminish offense by merely 10 % . To set every felon into a rehabilitation plan would be revenue enhancement remunerator much more.

New Zealand looks at offense in a different manner ; they do non go forth the determination devising merely up to those in jurisprudence and political relations. The correctional system allows the victim, wrongdoer, and the environing the community to come to an apprehension of the offense and develop and program to better the relationship between them. Harmonizing to Schmid ( 2001 ) this plan is really successful ; there is less than 10 % of recidivism. This program has received the International Community Justice Award in 2000, because it reduced reconvictions at a high rate and retained the populace ‘s assurances in the legal system.

When comparing the Cuban ‘s justness system to the U.S. , there is one major difference. That difference is that Cuba puts bulk of their attempts on rehabilitating felons over penalty or isolation. Inmates wear regular vesture, are able to keep normal occupations, and are incarcerated near their households irrespective of their offense. Elijah ( 2000 ) reported that if a captive ‘s sentence is less than five old ages they can go eligible for the “ conditional release plan. ” This plan gives prisoners the chance to work within the community without holding to inform the populace of their condemnable stats. This prevents them from being judged or un-excepted by others. In the U.S. many ex-convicts are non able to happen work, because their condemnable stats have to be public. The Conditional release plan allows wrongdoers to see their households outside of prison without supervising twice a month for three yearss. Prisoner ‘s that are involved in alternate plans has a recidivism rate is 15 % .

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 15

Mission to Carry through

The end is to make plans to assist captives and ex-convicts to turn away for a life of offense and go productive citizens. These plans have to be easy on tax-payers and profit the environing communities. The plans have to be able to rehabilitate, learn, and construct assurance. The mission is to make gradual alteration over a long period of clip, because a plan that has a great start, but do non last it is non consisted successful.

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 16

Chapter 3


Personal Ideas on Recidivism

Recidivism is an every turning job that if non controlled can hold damaging effects on society. Understanding why offense and recidivism happens can be narrowed down to four factors. First, offense occurs due to opportunity/Impulse. Opportunity/Impulse is when a possible felon feels that they are in the right topographic point in the right clip and everything can work in their favour. Second, offense occurs due to act upon. Influence can come from many different waies. Potential felons can be influence by a individual, groups or organisations. The 3rd factor is despair. When a individual becomes despairing they are capable of making anything. The proper plans should extinguish all of these factors to see

Research Questions

In analyzing recidivism there are two inquiries that is hoped to be answered to derive a better apprehension on the topic. The first inquiry is ; Can the condemnable head be rehabilitated or merely the ability to command one ‘s actions? And the 2nd inquiry is ; Make a individual ‘s thought procedures makes them condemnable or their actions? These inquiries will hold to be examined though psychological rating over a period of clip.

The first inquiry trades with the difference between interior alteration and compression actions. Is it true that one time a condemnable ever a felon? An illustration ; A former larceny walks into a shop and sees jewelry lying on a tabular array and there no 1 about. If they think about stealing the jewellery, he thinks about how he can take it and finds his flight, but does non, is this

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 17

rehabilitation or merely command? Image if this same individual walked into the shop and ne’er thought about stealing the jewellery lying on the tabular array, this leads into the 2nd inquiry.

Does the idea of stealing the jewellery make a individual a condemnable or merely the action of stealing? In the same since, the thought and planning to slay a individual is a offense. So the million dollar inquiry is, does this “ rehabilitated ” ex-criminal still perpetrating the offense of confederacy? The possibility of a individual who lived a life of offense being changed would be a great success for them and the populace.


For the research of recidivism the sample would be to utilize 1,000 captives with all degrees of offenses. These captives will come from all over the U.S. who is one to two old ages off from being released or paroled. Dividing the sample into race would be the same ratios that are incarcerated. Harmonizing to Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration ( 2009 ) there are 10 % of inkinesss, 9 A? % of American Indians or Alaska Natives, 8 % of Whites, 7 % of Native Hawaiians, and 6 % of Hispanics that are incarcerated in the U.S. The survey would dwell of all males, because males have the highest degree of recidivism rates. The per centums would be adjusted to include the 1,000 captive and the right ratio.

Research Design

Puting up a research design to analyze recidivism has to get down foremost with plans that need to be tested. The plan that will be tested would be a two portion program. The first program will get down while the inmates are still in prison. The 2nd program will get down one time the inmate is released or paroled.

Runing caput: Determination A CURE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES 18